Nashville

(dir. Robert Altman, 1975)

May 12, 2008

Nashville poster (usable).jpg

”We must be doin’ somethin’ right to last 200 years”…

Back in 1975, Robert Altman thoughtfully released a big, sprawling, dynamically disorganized motion picture called “Nashville” that served as an un-posed snapshot of the bruised American character, just so we’d have a better grasp of the swelling once the Bicentennial rolled around. And it turned out to be one of the more viciously entertaining movies ever made. The most effective of the several posters for “Nashville” - Paramount had absolutely no idea how to market the film - described it as “The damndest thing you ever saw,” and that’s as good a description as I could possibly muster. A lot of people, including some critics, got pissed off about the ramshackle nature of the movie, and hardly anybody went to see it. But, given its poke-them-with-a-stick tone, and the fact that one of the loudest critics was whiney-ass Rex Reed, Altman might have considered that a badge of honor.

                                                ***

It’s difficult to even convey what Altman pulled off here; when it’s spelled out in front of you it seems like a free-range mess. He and his screenwriter, Joan Tewksebury, whipped up a patchwork quilt of 24 key characters, spread them around Music City during a Presidential campaign, and, to a large degree, had the cast improvise what took place. There was a pre-conceived script, up to a point, but it mainly served as a rough outline. I happen to have a copy of that original screenplay, and it bears only a passing resemblance to the sort of thing that guides a conventional Hollywood production. Tewksebury even included back-stories about the characters that play no part in the narrative. The incidents never even get mentioned in passing. It was all there to give the actors something to hang onto while they discovered the “story,” and the cast Altman gathered - many of whom had very little big-screen experience - delivered in high style.

Where to begin? Since they took the time to compile a description, I suppose I’ll just go ahead and show you Paramount’s breathless trailer for the film:


And that’s not including Julie Christie and Elliot Gould, work buddies of Altman’s who were passing through town during the shoot and agreed to make cameos as themselves. For her trouble, Christie gets nailed with a withering, on-screen putdown by Black, one of the funniest lines in the picture. No target was safe in the universe Altman created for “Nashville,” a fact that’s conveyed quite literally in the final, devastating sequence. Again, a lot of people were unhappy with how Altman wrapped things up. But how can you convey the madness of America without including a gun?

At this point, some technical background is in order, since it so thoroughly shaped what became “Nashville.” Altman shot the more populated scenes in long-shot, then zoomed in on performers when he thought they were doing something especially interesting. So, in many situations, the actors didn’t even know when they were on camera. And, just to further complicate things, Altman and his brilliant sound engineers, Jim Webb and Jac Cashin, designed and built a groundbreaking 8-track recording system that allowed them to individually record numerous characters at the same time. Then, during the mixing process, they slowly raised and lowered the various soundtracks at the same speed that the camera moved from one character to another, so that one voice would fade into the background while the other took center stage— they called it a “sound zoom.” Altman also decided which pieces of extraneous dialogue, much of which is hilarious, would jostle for position with whatever was now the focus of the scene. In effect, he guided the viewer’s attention with the sound mix rather than just the images.

Nobody had ever done anything remotely like this before…except for Altman, who toyed with it on his previous film, the gambling-addiction comedy, “California Split.” Because of the ingenious recording techniques, it’s possible to watch “Nashville” over and over again, and still pick up exchanges that you missed every other time. It’s the movie equivalent of a great Dylan song, a puzzle that you can never quite solve.

God only knows how it worked so well. Altman made as many shitty movies as any major director, and I mean really miserable pictures. But when the pieces fell into place, as they did with “Nashville,” the results feel totally natural, as if you’re watching some kind of accidental masterwork. If you have any interest at all in how far-gone the American experiment had gotten by the mid-1970s, you can’t help but get involved in it. But try not to shudder at how much worse it is now.

                                                ***

Robert Altman (shrunk).jpg

There’s a hell of a lot going on in “Nashville,” but Altman - pretty far ahead of the game at that point - strongly suggests that politics, when you get right down to it, is nothing but an extension of show business. Or maybe he’s saying that the rich and famous that walk among us are just as lost as everyone else, regardless of the so-called promise of complete “freedom.” Or maybe that’s just what concerns me when I consider the “Nashville” tableau.

Again, the swirl of events offers up a wide variety of interpretations, so here’s a list of the characters that hit me the hardest when I watch the movie. Your attention will be at least partially drawn in different directions, and you may even interpret the actions of these characters differently than I do:

* Haven Hamilton (Henry Gibson) is the overlord of “Nashville,” the King of Country Music whose folksy smarm barely conceals a massive ego and driving ambition. “Nashville”’s opening sequence - during which Hamilton records a bullshit-laden paean to, among other things, the glory of getting shot up in American wars - is jaw-dropping, a fittingly audacious opening salvo. There’s something disquieting about this character and his Hank Snow-white jumpsuits. He’s a peculiar mixture of compassion and calculation, a frightening boss-man who knows a sellable tune when he hears one, then proceeds to sell the living shit out of it. No wonder he’s being wooed for a transition into politics.

* Barbara Jean (Ronee Blakely) is America’s sweetheart, the country music survivor in the full-length prairie dress who’s just a couple steps away from being completely bonkers. Blakely’s big moment is an excruciating, extended meltdown on the stage at Opryland that quickly moves between sweet reminiscence and outright horror. Much as Randy Newman does with his most effective character studies - that’ll be a different column - Altman allows viewers to implicate themselves when they impulsively laugh at something that turns out to be extraordinarily ugly. Unnerving art, it would seem, requires an unnerving audience.


* Barnett (Allen Garfield) is Barbara Jean’s gruff, harried manager-husband. Barbara Jean’s career would seem to be Barnett’s main concern, but there are moments when he shows surprising sweetness and compassion toward her. He’s as complex a minor character as you’ll find in any American movie, even though Garfield and Altman almost came to blows during filming because Garfield inexplicably wanted his girlfriend to write his dialogue!

* Linnea Reese (Lily Tomlin) is the only white singer in an otherwise all-black gospel choir. She’s married to Delbert, a hard-working local businessman (Ned Beatty) who’s helping set up a fundraiser for a Presidential candidate. Linnea and Delbert’s children are deaf, and it’s a telling moment when you realize that Delbert has never even bothered to learn sign language so he can readily communicate with them. But Linnea’s story becomes one of “Nashville”’s more fascinating strands when she unwisely attempts an affair with an over-sexed rock star (Keith Carradine). Tomlin’s quietly shattering performance could be the best in the entire movie, but she’s not even remotely convincing as a gospel singer. Her song is one of the briefest on the soundtrack, for good reason. Otherwise, this is the strongest work of Tomlin’s career.

* Lady Pearl (Barbara Baxley) is Haven Hamilton’s aggressive, hard-drinking wife. Although she gets less screen time than many of the other actors, Baxley makes every second count. In the early going, she has a screamingly hysterical argument with Gibson about the correct lyrics of song they both vaguely remember, and, later, she delivers a strange, heartfelt monologue about her commitment to John and Bobby Kennedy. You can’t quite put your finger on Pearl. She seems simultaneously smarter and less perceptive than Haven, a woman with a lot of heart and character who’s somehow ended up a cog in an absurd showbiz machine. As crazy as she can appear, you feel like she deserves better.

* Hal Phillip Walker (the voice of Thomas Hal Phillips) is the never-seen third-party presidential candidate (for The Replacement Party.) Walker’s campaign van, which tools through town blaring his simplistic but sometimes perceptive revisionist political speeches, serves as the connective tissue between the characters. Just as he did with the humorous public address announcements in M*A*S*H, Altman repeatedly uses Walker’s ramblings as a kind of aural wipe between settings and situations— when the van shows up, he just follows it down the road to another location. It’s an ingenious way of making such a wide-ranging film hold together. Phillips, the guy who wrote and delivered the speeches, was a real-life southern political wheeler-dealer who genuinely believed everything “Walker” said. Years later, it was noted that his cockeyed cynicism-optimism was a dead ringer for the intellectual chicken-scratchings put forth by Ross Perot during his failed Presidential bid.

Be prepared— there’s a lot of music in “Nashville,” and Altman often sticks with an entire performance, from beginning to end. The actors also wrote their own songs (!) so some of the tunes are less effective than others. But all of them serve a much broader purpose than the songs do in most “traditional” musicals.

In “Nashville,” you not only learn about the characters through the songs they sing, you realize they're selling a particular perception of themselves as people. The film’s viewers, in other words, can tell when they’re lying. This unique little twist adds considerable depth to "Nashville"'s music, and turns even the lesser songs into wryly ironic adventures. (Carradine, by the way, actually won an Oscar for his singer-songwriter confessional, “I’m Easy,” which wouldn’t have sounded out of place on a Jim Croce album from the period.)

Over the course of its 160 minute running time, “Nashville” is “about” many different things. But, at its core, it concerns itself with America's unending capacity for finding all the false truths it can devour. Yes, politics is the same as show business, and show business is the same as politics. But in the end, the only reality is that we all get royally screwed by the madness of the system.

Somebody ought to write a song about it.

Paul Tatara

Tags:
RSS Feed