Sept. 25, 2009
Download It #27: Fleet Foxes
.jpg)
I don’t stumble upon interesting new rock bands as often as I used to, mainly because rock & roll is no longer the key prism through which I view the world. I just don’t read about rock all that much these days, whereas I used to do it constantly. Plus, and this is a big one, I’ve got enough great jazz cd’s strewn about the apartment to keep me occupied at least until I die, and maybe even beyond that, if they let you bring cd’s to the afterlife. I’m guessing the equipment won’t be compatible.
Once in a while, though, I’ll pick up a relatively eloquent British music magazine - American music critics sound like thesaurus-thumbing retards - and dig around for someone “new,” which is to say, someone I haven’t heard before, even if they’ve been around for a while. More often than not, the search is beyond futile. But, about four months ago, I hit pay dirt with a powerful Seattle folk band, of sorts, named Fleet Foxes; they’ve been an enormous commercial and critical hit in England for the past year, but have attracted only a sizable cult following in the United States.
I’ve played Fleet Foxes’ self-titled first album (they’ve also released an excellent EP) about fifty times over now, and still haven’t reached the bottom of their minor chord musings. These guys are capable of giving me goose bumps when I’m in the right mood, and I thought I was well beyond the age where a bunch of unshaven twenty-somethings in smelly-looking clothes could do that to me.
.jpg)
It’s hard to label Fleet Foxes’ sound, which makes listening to them all the more enjoyable. At times they resemble a cross between The Beach Boys, The Beatles, and early Neil Young, but doses of Dylan, Joni Mitchell, Richard Thompson, and, due to lead singer-songwriter Robin Pecknold’s pop bent, even Simon & Garfunkel are thrown in for good measure.
Certainly, a vague Celtic tinge shades many of their melodies, but these guys are as American as any band now making a dent on iTunes. Their harmonies, which are consistently stunning, sound like they’re floating down from the mountaintop, and the acoustic bent to their arrangements evokes log cabins and wood-burning stoves without sounding like an affectation.
Ultimately, I have to opt for The Band as the real forerunner to Fleet Foxes, but in feel rather than sound. Both groups reveal an earthy range of influences that have somehow generated roots of their own; the songs are oddly recognizable yet unique, and the spirit of an earlier, haunted republic permeates both bands’ worldview. Fleet Foxes rock from deep within such outdated concepts as family and community, rather than through an agent and an auto-tuner, and they’re not the least bit ashamed of it. They’re old-fashioned, but only in the sense that they truly seem to believe.
***
There’s not a dud track on “Fleet Foxes.” Even the ones that aren’t quite as interesting lyrically are built around vaguely baroque arrangements full of swirling organs and pounding drums that suggest Dylan’s “All Along the Watchtower” landscape of pampered Lords and Ladies mixed with the darker elements of the American frontier. If this is genre music, it’s a genre that, to lift a phrase from Vonnegut, has come “unstuck in time.” You feel like it’s simply lighted here temporarily during a journey through the mists.
Fleet Foxes’ big hit in England, “White Winter Hymnal,” is a haunting little madrigal that, not surprisingly, most American kids have zipped right past during prepackaged grease-runs to McDonald’s. Like so many other songs on the album, “White Winter Hymnal” is built around a timpani figure and a mix of electric and acoustic guitars, but the vocals are the real story. All the band members work on Fleet Foxes’ arrangements, and they’re also credited, R.E.M.-style, as co-writers. There’s a warm, organic beauty to the finished product that, you have to figure, could only arise from the interaction of a group of close friends.
"White Winter Hymnal"
I was following the pack
all swallowed in their coats
with scarves of red tied ‘round their throats
to keep their little heads
from falling in the snow
And I turned ‘round and there you go
And, Michael, you would fall
and turn the white snow red as strawberries
in summertime…
We’ve obviously entered the world of a childhood memory here, but the tune’s lack of specifics imbues it with a dreamlike quality that stands up to repeatedly listening. It’s a prayer to the past, with a little blood thrown in just to keep it honest. The only way this would be a hit in the United States is if Lady Gaga sang it buck naked on the final episode of “American Idol.”
Another pivotal track on the record, “He Doesn’t Know Why,” may well be my favorite. A prodigal son tale told from the perspective of an astonished brother, it rises on a soaring melody that, with its minor chord statements, implies the exhilaration of the open road with the sadness of leaving behind the people who love you. There’s a strong suggestion that the person the narrator sings about is now damaged goods, but he’ll undoubtedly be hitting the road again once he deigns to let his still-loving family reground him. Again, there’s something unspoken here that gives the song an unnerving edge.
"He Doesn't Know Why"
Penniless and tired, with your hair grown long
I was looking at you there and your face looked wrong
Memory is a fickle siren song
I didn't understand
In the gentle light as the morning nears
You don't say a single word of your last two years
Well you will when you've reached the frontier
I didn't understand, no
See your rugged hands and a silver knife
Twenty dollars in your hand that you hold so tight
All the evidence of your vacant life
My brother you were born
And you will try to do what you did before
Pull the wool over your eyes
For a week or more
Let your family take you back to your original mind
There's nothing I can do
There's nothing I can do
There's nothing I can say
There's nothing I can say
I can say
Those are Ringo drum fills, by the way, that sort of slap-happy, counter-intuitive thing that leaves you slightly hanging in its appealing eccentricity. Between that and the consistent use of timpani, Fleet Foxes may be the first Beatles-influenced band to give Mr. Starkey a place in the driver’s seat.
***
.jpg)
For all their communal spirit, Pecknold appears to be the real force behind Fleet Foxes. He’s certainly the media face of the band, and he and guitar player Skye Skjelset founded the group when their shared love of Dylan and Neil Young drew them together as Seattle high school students. That was…um…about five years ago.
Pecknold’s work on “Fleet Foxes” is astonishingly mature for a guy who just turned 23 years-old, but he’s been immersed in melody his entire life. His dad played in a Seattle soul band called The Fathoms in the 1960s, and the Pecknolds are music-oriented enough that Robin's sister is named Aja, after the 1977 Steely Dan album. Pecknold claims he was so withdrawn as a youth that he never attended a party until Fleet Foxes signed a record deal, and that he’s still too self-conscious to have any real friends outside of the other band members, whom he loves as family.
Pecknold’s crowning achievement on “Fleet Foxes” would have to be the album’s breathtaking closing track, “Oliver James.” The story of a young girl who finds an abandoned child by the banks of a river, the song is imbued with the mythology of baby Moses’ escape from the Pharaohs while giving two lost souls salvation in the form of deep, abiding love. I’m telling you, this is just a gorgeous, gorgeous song.
"Oliver James"
On the way to your brother's house in the valley deep
By the river bridge a cradle floating beside me
In the whitest water on the bank against the stone
You will lift his body from the shore and bring him home
Oliver James washed in the rain no longer
Oliver James washed in the rain no longer
On the kitchen table that your grandfather did make
You in your delicate way will slowly clean his face
And you will remember when you rehearsed the actions of
An innocent and anxious mother full of anxious love
Oliver James washed in the rain no longer
Oliver James washed in the rain no longer
Walk with me down ruby beach and through the valley floor
Love for the one you know more
Love for the one you know more
Back we go to your brother's house emptier my dear
The sound of ancient voices ringing soft upon your ear
Oliver James washed in the rain no longer
Oliver James washed in the rain no longer
This guy is 23 years-old?! Really? What’ll he have in store for us when he’s actually lived a life?
***
You can hear the wood creak and the rivers flow in Fleet Foxes music, and their lyrics touch upon a mythic, purer world that may or may not have existed before you and I made an appearance. If you’re not paying attention, they can come off as anachronistic hippies, but their obvious belief in the human spirit - and in a great tune - saves them every time. I’ve grown convinced that “Fleet Foxes,” is a classic American album, one of the great debuts of the past 20 years. You need to pick it up.
Paul Tatara
Greg Pecknold:
I'm the unofficial archivist for Fleet Foxes (as well as the father of Robin) and I just wanted to say that of all the reviews and interviews I have collected and read (with a fathers pride) for the past few years, your review was possibly one of the most accurate and resonant with my recollection of the history surrounding the band. You touched upon the most significant truths about them and called out their special qualities in a wonderful way. Thanks for sharing their story with your readers. I will visit again to see what other treasures you have to share.
Thanks,
Greg Pecknold